Case reports

Tax / TV presenter Helen Fospero wins £80k IR35 case

In the latest IR35 loss for HMRC, TV presenter Helen Fospero has won her case at the tax tribunal over a disputed tax bill of £80,000 when she was working on a contract basis for ITV

Tax / Gaines-Cooper returns to tribunal over disputed £30m tax bill

Multimillionaire Robert Gaines-Cooper is back in the tax courts at the First Tier Tribunal disputing a long-running avoidance case centring on tax liability and domicile issues

Tax / IT contractor wins £240k IR35 appeal

HMRC has lost its latest legal challenge on the operation of the off-payroll rules, after a First Tier Tribunal (FTT) found in favour of an IT contractor

Tax / BBC presenter Ackroyd loses appeal over £400k tax liability

The Upper Tribunal has rejected an appeal by TV presenter Christa Ackroyd over her tax status at the BBC, stating that she must pay NICs and income tax on her earnings, as she was an employee not a contractor

Tax / HMRC wins GAAR ruling on employee shareholder share abuse

The GAAR advisory panel has issued a ruling clamping down on a scheme involving the extraction of cash or value from a company by its directors and shareholders using employee shareholder shares

Tax / VAT updates: October 2019

In this month’s VAT updates, Graham Elliott, director at City & Cambridge Consultancy, considers litigation costs in Newmafruit Farms, whether a diary is a book, zero rated grass seed, works for disabled people and child protection services

Tax / Tax updates: October 2019

In this month’s tax updates, three BBC presenters lose IR35 case, Apple tax demand ‘defies reality’, Glencore wins £51m transfer pricing appeal, HMRC does not understand small business, 120,000 miss MTD deadline, double NIC Brexit warning, and NHS pension tax consultation

Tax / Starbucks wins €30m case over disputed Dutch tax bill

Starbucks has won a long-running tax case against the European Commission over accusations that it subverted state aid rules to reduce its tax bill in the Netherlands

Tax / HMRC loses sight of argument in Koolmove case

In this First Tier Tribunal case, the appellant Koolmove Ltd appealed against the denial by HMRC of amounts of input VAT claimed for pre-incorporation legal services. Aleem Islan, technical consultation manager at AAT, examines the ruling and the reasons for HMRC’s loss of the case

Tax / BBC presenters lose in IR35 ‘chaos’

HMRC has won a First Tier Tribunal (FTT) case concerning the employment status of three BBC presenters who used personal service companies (PSCs), in an IR35 ruling involving over £300,000 in tax which threatens to add to the ‘chaos’ around how the employment rules should be applied

Tax / Ireland loses €10m aluminium EU state aid tax argument

Ireland and Italy have lost a lengthy battle to overturn an EU demand for the recovery of millions of euros in taxes from two aluminium metal manufacturers, following a judgment that a tax exemption amounted to illegal state aid

Tax / US regulator slams Prudential over $200m tax reorganisation

Two US subsidiaries of financial services giant Prudential Financial have been censured by the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for failing to disclose conflicts of interest and making misleading disclosures, after they were reorganised so that Prudential received over $200m (£160m) in tax benefits to the detriment of funds they advised

Tax / EU tax demand for €13bn from Apple ‘defies reality’

IT giant Apple and the Irish government are at the EU general court this week, challenging a ruling that the company should pay €13bn (£11.5bn) in back taxes

Tax / Google hit with €1bn French tax payment

The French government is claiming a ‘historic’ victory in a long running tax battle with Google, after reaching a €945m (£845m) settlement with the tech giant over tax fraud allegations

Tax / Glencore wins £51m transfer pricing tax appeal

Anglo-Swiss multinational mining group Glencore has won a A$92m (£51m) victory in a long-running transfer pricing dispute with the Australian Taxation Office (ATO)