ICAS signals opportunity to reform complex tax system
15 Jun 2020
The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland (ICAS) has called for a number of reforms and more informed public debate in ‘The Future of Taxation in the UK’ report
15 Jun 2020
The Future of Taxation in the UK, published by the ICAS Tax Board, identifies the government is unwilling to increase the main revenue-raising taxes as a contributing factor towards increasingly complex and lengthy tax legislation, which makes it harder for taxpayers (particularly unrepresented ones) to understand and comply with their tax obligations.
Bruce Cartwright CA, ICAS chief executive, said: ‘There has been considerable uncertainty in recent years, for businesses and individuals, following the outcome of the EU referendum and the prolonged Brexit process.
‘The coronavirus pandemic has added a whole new layer of uncertainty but it may also present the government with an opportunity to generate public support for tax reform.
‘This has previously been difficult to achieve but the aftermath of the pandemic, with strong public support for the NHS, might be the ideal moment for a public debate about who should pay tax and how much they should contribute.’
It is ICAS’ belief that a lack of understanding of an overly complex system, combined with a perception that there has been widespread abuse, has contributed to a sense of unfairness amongst the public which undermines voluntary compliance.
Examples of abuse and problems with the international tax system have been widely publicised but far less publicity has been given to successes in combatting tax avoidance, or to the work of the OECD (supported by the government) to reform international tax.
This issue should form part of a wider public dialogue, facilitated by the government, about the part taxation plays in society and its role in supporting public services and the common good.
The report states that there has been a considerable amount of change to the business landscape over recent years, affecting both firms and individuals.
Increasing digitalisation and developments in Artificial Intelligence (AI) have seen older ‘bricks and mortar’ businesses struggle to compete against new global online businesses.
The growth of the gig economy has presented opportunities for some but led to exploitation of others and the government provision of coronavirus support schemes has shone a light on these trends.
ICAS noted that taxation sometimes struggles to keep up with these changes, both in policy terms and in tax administration, and outlines a series of recommendations for addressing key issues affecting the future of taxation in the UK.
Charlotte Barbour, ICAS director of taxation, added: ‘The ICAS Tax Board is seeking a public discussion exploring the role of tax in supporting public services and contributing to the common good – please contact us to share your views.’
By Zak Jakubowski